Fall 2026 Menu
Enjoy Chef Geno McWilliams’ Italian cooking from our open kitchen, with every dish prepared to order. Order at the front counter, and we’ll bring your food to your table. Soft drinks are self-serve, and you’re welcome to bring your own wine.
Deconstructed Grilled Cheese
It’s a secret.
19
Chili Butter Carrots
Chili, butter, popcorn pine nuts
19
Lost Bread
Italian bread, egg, cream, maple bourbon honey
19
Caesar Salad
Romaine, croutons, 24-month Parmigiano Reggiano
16
Fresh Garden Salad
Seasonal vegetables, balsamic vinaigrette, French dressing
15
Crostini
Whipped ricotta, braised onion, Calabrian honey
17
Salsiccia La Zucchina
Handmade sausage, white wine, garlic, zucchini
27
Bucatini Scarpariello
San Marzano, garlic, basil, chili
27
Lasagne
Bolognese, bechamel, pecorino romano
24
Wild Mushroom Pappardelle
Wild mushroom, cream, garlic
27
Rigatoni
Sausage, garlic, peas, sugo, cream
27
Carbonara
Guanciale, egg yolk, black pepper, pecorino romano
27
Margherita
San Marzano, Fior di Latte, basil, EVOO
27
Meat & More Meat
Italian sausage, pepperoni, Nueske’s, capicola
29
Cicero
Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, S&P, chili, Pecorino Romano
29
Cosenza
Double pepperoni, ricotta, basil, hot honey, shaved chocolate
24
Trentino
Wild mushroom, Fior di Latte, Italian sausage, mozzarella, provolone, Parmigiano Reggiano
24
Grandma George’s Chocolate Cake
Geno’s childhood birthday cake. Trust us… it’s amazing.
14
Luciano
Cookie butter gelato, house whip, biscotti cookie, brown butter
14
Affogato
Madagascar vanilla gelato, espresso, house whip, shaved chocolate
14
Espresso
Our espresso is Lavazza, shipped in from Italy.
3
Cannoli
We use the best ricotta in the country. Sweet ricotta, chocolate chip, icing sugar
9
Customer Testimonials
We value every customer’s dining experience!
We shared a garden salad, deconstructed grilled cheese, carbonara, pepperoni pizza with hot honey and the chocolate cake. All was magnifico. We will definitely be back.
Trisha Kiwior
October 25, 2025
Absolutely loved the food…Alfredo was heavenly. Girls at the reception are really helpful. Will surely visit again when in Effingham.
Syed
October 9, 2025
We ordered pizzas, but they only come in 1 size and are pretty expensive for what you get. The food was good and servers were nice. Not a lot of options though and prices are high.
Jennifer Matthews
October 5, 2025
Amazing Food!
Tamara Martin
October 4, 2025
A lovely little gem! The atmosphere was pleasant and the staff were very helpful! Lastly, the food was delicious!! Highly recommend a visit even if you’re just passing through town!
Erin A
September 26, 2025
Food was amazing we had the pizza and Ceasar salad the home made sauces for the pizza and salad were so rich, so flavorful. The chef was so friendly and explained the roots of the restaurant. It was a great experience and amazing food.
L.J. Goheen
September 19, 2025
4.6 FROM OVER465 REVIEWS
Experience A Taste Of Italy At Lucia’s
Every visit to Lucia’s Italian Kitchen promises to be a memorable occasion for you and your loved ones.